Category Archives: Uncategorized

If the tzitz – the frontplate worn by the priest – a magical object? On today’s daf we learn that if the kometz (handful of gran taken for the meal offering) becomes ritually impure, and is still offered on the altar, the offering is accepted. Why? Because of the tzitz, the golden frontplate worn byContinue reading “Menachot 25”

On today’s daf we learn that sometimes a meal offering was placed in a container that was divided into separate sections. I think school cafeteria: The Gemara explains that even though flour/meal offering from two different offerings is physically separated within the vessel, it is still treated as one unified offering, because it is allContinue reading “Menachot 24”

Be careful who you hang out with. And Rabbi Ḥanina says the opposite: Any small quantity of an item that can possibly become like the item that is present in larger quantities is not nullified when the two are intermingled, but any small quantity of an item that cannot possibly become like the item thatContinue reading “Menachot 23”

What a gem today. The Gemara imagines a very intuitive assumption:If I bring my own offering, of course I bring my own wood.After all, I bring my own animal. I bring my own libations. And the Torah says: No. You may bring your korban/sacrifice—but the wood and fire are never yours.They belong to the community.Continue reading “Menachot 22”

Is it Jewish to be salty? Salt was an integral part of each and every sacrifice, as the Torah clearly states in Leviticus 2:3, that the covenant of salt should never be left out when bringing sacrifices. We see this on our daf today: the salt is placed in three locations in the Temple: InContinue reading “Menachot 21”

My favorite line from our daf today: just as it is impossible for the offerings to be sacrificed without the involvement of the priesthood, so too, it is impossible for the offerings to be sacrificed without salt. There is no holiness without sweat and tears. Sacrifice that ignores either the holy or the drudgery fails.Continue reading “Menachot 20”

Okay, this line jumped right out at me today: One cannot derive the possible from the impossible. Wow. If your starting point is flawed or impossible, whatever you try to learn from it collapses. In rabbinic legal reasoning, this is a basic rule of logic: you can’t build law or meaning on a hypothetical thatContinue reading “Menachot 19”

Today’s gem is so good. The joy found in learning an opinion that you don’t even agree with – just to know you’re not crazy that one exists. And the joy and blessings the teacher feels when he sees how much his student loves Torah. I found Yosef the Babylonian sitting before Rabbi Elazar benContinue reading “Menachot 18”

Today’s page of the Talmud opens with a curious phrase: “So say the sharp people in the city of Pumbedita:,” before presenting a legal teaching. But who were these “sharp people”? The Talmud isn’t talking about a crowd or a general reputation. In another tractate, Sanhedrin (17b), we learn that this was actually a nicknameContinue reading “Menachot 17”

What do you mean by that? In the case of a meal offering, the parts that the priests are allowed to eat do not become permitted until two steps have taken place: the kometz—a handful of flour taken for the altar—and the levona, the frankincense, are both placed on the altar. The Mishnah on today’sContinue reading “Menachot 16”